Re: Katte

Date: 2022-09-05 11:27 am (UTC)
mildred_of_midgard: (Default)
From: [personal profile] mildred_of_midgard
Remind me, Spaen wasn't the one with the teacups, that was Ingerssomething or the other, right?

Correct, Ingersleben is our teacup man!

To quote [personal profile] prinzsorgenfrei: Ingersleben, like Keith, Katte, and Fritz himself, gets a list of stuff found in his rooms and among the things found are "Three and a half dozen teacups made of real porcelain" :'D For comparison: Lieutenant von Spaen, who gets a list of his own, too, owns "four teacups made of real porcelain" and Fritz has 11 in two different places. Spaen also owns four napkins while Ingersleben has t w e n t y. Maybe Ingersleben is hosting tea parties for the whole regiment, who knows. If more than 42 people show up, he can still serve them tea in "six chocolate-cups made of real porcelain".Average Prussian Lieutenant owns 10 porcelain cups factoid actually statistical error. Lieutenant Johann Ludwig von Ingersleben, who owns 48 porcelain cups minimum, is an outlier and should not have been counted.Though I have to admit, my favourite weird thing from the lists is the point on Katte's (who doesn't get a full list but only a list of stuff that the people checking the place thought might have belonged to Fritz, too bad) that just says "a heart". I mean, I ASSUME it's a charm, but it really just says "a heart" and I think that's wonderfully ominous :'D

Speaking of Trick or Treat fairy-tale motifs! To quote you:

Heart: sorry, [personal profile] mildred_of_midgard, I have no idea. Though the Sandman and fairy tale reader in me now wonders whether you could construct a fairy tale version whether the heart was from Fritz, which he gave to Katte to keep, and which ended up in the Prussian State's possession, hence the entirety of the rest of Fritz' life!

Though Spaen shows up in Nicolai, I think?

Also correct!

Frederick the Great had done nothing for Spaen after his ascension; but when he travelled to Kleve in the year 1763, he did take lodgings with General von Spaen, was very gracious and confidential towards him, reminded him of stories of their shared youth, but did not mention the year 1730 with one word; which is why General von Spaen used to joke that the King had an excellent memory right up to 1730.

Kloosterhuis says Spaen was cashiered, imprisoned 3 years in in Spandau (starting November 7, 1730), and then went into Dutch service.

I can see why you would want Fritz to acknowledge you made a sacrifice!

THERAPY FOR EVERYONE

Re: the second excerpt, I see the conclusion as a bit more ambigously - the "If he did go, I would try to get free from here" can also mean that Katte, still recounting his conversation with Spaen, told Spaen that if he were Spaen, he'd follow Fritz in the event that Fritz does manage to escape.

Ahh, yes. Could be. I saw multiple ways of interpreting that sentence, but I didn't come up with that one. Interesting!

Katte, why so ambiguous?? Twenty-first century readers need to know!

It's entirely possible Katte was more quickly into Fritz than Fritz was into him, though that's the reverse of how all the fictionalisations I'm aware of play it. :)

Right? But given that Fritz is CROWN PRINCE, and Katte is someone Fritz took an immediate dislike to and had to be won around, I could see it playing out so that Katte falls first.

Roes: Yeah, my impression is that he's super side-eyeing all the crazy 18th century stuff he sees/gets involved in, like duels and hazing rituals (like riding horses into people's salons), and, like, it's entirely possible that Katte was totally into all this. :P We know (or at least strongly deduce) that Katte was reluctant to join the escape attempt, given the evidence that Fritz had to lie to him, but...maybe that's a case of, "You know your escape plan is poorly thought out when even Lieutenant Hans Hermann 'My middle name is Impulsive' von Katte thinks it's a bad idea," rather than "Katte's fate in life is to always find himself playing the role of Only Sane Man."

(I'm now imagining a scenario where Katte *does* make an impulse trip all the way to Madrid, only he hasn't bothered to find out that 1) Rottembourg isn't ambassador any more, 2) the Spanish court is in Andalusia, and thus Katte's very surprised when he arrives. Speaking of which, [personal profile] prinzsorgenfrei needs to get the unpublished Martin von Katte material from Maria von Katte and share it with us!)

Re: Katte

Date: 2022-09-06 08:03 am (UTC)
selenak: (DadLehndorff)
From: [personal profile] selenak
Thank you for reminding me of the heart in Katte's possession and my fairy tale thought!



Kloosterhuis says Spaen was cashiered, imprisoned 3 years in in Spandau (starting November 7, 1730), and then went into Dutch service.

I can see why you would want Fritz to acknowledge you made a sacrifice!


Peter Keith: Join the club.
Doris Ritter: MEN.
Duhan: He acknowledged me! With the same text as Algarotti, no less!

Right? But given that Fritz is CROWN PRINCE, and Katte is someone Fritz took an immediate dislike to and had to be won around, I could see it playing out so that Katte falls first.

Trying to think of it: is there a (pro)fictional version which even includes Fritz originally being distant? Let alone Katte falling for him first (even in a platonic version)? I can't think of one. (In Roes, he's sorry for Fritz the moment he sees him, but the later emotional and then physical intimacy is all initialized by Fritz. And let's not even mention the Katte/Wilhelmine shipping musical in this context.) Despite, as you say, it making sense.

HOWEVER, and speaking of [personal profile] prinzsorgenfrei: her stories about Katte and Fritz, especially the last one, are the only ones I can think of where Katte has that cheerful energy which salon has decided he must have had (like Keyslerlingk and Algarotti, evidently something Fritz was attracted to) and you can see the two of them having fun instead of being all doomed intensity with each other.

maybe that's a case of, "You know your escape plan is poorly thought out when even Lieutenant Hans Hermann 'My middle name is Impulsive' von Katte thinks it's a bad idea," rather than "Katte's fate in life is to always find himself playing the role of Only Sane Man."

*nods* And that's why in an AU where Fritz successfully escapes, and Katte as well, you'd have to change the plan, methinks.

Re: Katte

Date: 2022-09-18 08:43 pm (UTC)
mildred_of_midgard: (Default)
From: [personal profile] mildred_of_midgard
Duhan: He acknowledged me! With the same text as Algarotti, no less!

He called you his true father! He visited your deathbed and wrote nice things about himself in the third person for doing so! (iirc)

I'm not sure why you're never listed among the "The only person Fritz ever REALLY loved was" statements that biographers love making.

Trying to think of it: is there a (pro)fictional version which even includes Fritz originally being distant?

I mean, I'm not the (pro)fictional expert here, but nothing is coming to mind. And this is the guy who the trial records said initially took a dislike to Katte!

HOWEVER, and speaking of [personal profile] prinzsorgenfrei: her stories about Katte and Fritz, especially the last one, are the only ones I can think of where Katte has that cheerful energy which salon has decided he must have had

Gaah, I am so behind on fanfic! But that is good to know. And good for her!

(like Keyslerlingk and Algarotti, evidently something Fritz was attracted to)

Based on things Fritz wrote, I think he was attracted to it because he had depressive tendencies/PTSD, and being around cheerful people had a tonic effect on him. <3 I think Peter lost out because he *didn't* have this going for him.

Profile

cahn: (Default)
cahn

February 2026

S M T W T F S
1 2 34567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 5th, 2026 02:51 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios