"Last in a Series" bingo was going to be a tricky one, because what series are there that I haven't read all of/can complete while doing twenty-four other unrelated authors? (Thursday Next almost worked, but "Dark Reading Matter" is now delayed to 2026.) So when I saw a "fantasy mountain climbing" duology among Yuletide fandom recs, it was like, sure, I'll try a duology, we don't need to do hard mode here. "All the Wandering Light" follows directly on from "Even the Darkest Stars," and I wouldn't say the plot/characterization work well as a standalone, so this will really be a (spoilery) dual review.
Kamzin and her sister Lusha live in the village of Azmiri; their mother was a famous mountain climber, and so they know the path to the unclimbed Mount Raksha, the tallest mountain in the world. The renowned Royal Explorer, River Shara, wants to climb it, and Kamzin is desperate to accompany him and have an adventure. In the sequel, Kamzin and Lusha discover a falling star, which holds magical power which might be the key to saving the empire from fearsome witches, so they have to track that down in another mountain range and then deliver it to the emperor.
The "fantasy Himalayas" stuff is more prominent in the first book than the second. Raksha is "only" about twenty thousand feet tall, which is more like the Alps than the Himalayas--no need for fantasy!bottled oxygen, etc. There are some artifacts known as
kinnika that are magical bells (I think more like jingle bells and cowbells than musical bells), which was neat. In general, I was more interested in the mountain climbing than the "weird evil creatures" stuff.
I can recommend this if you like cute animal sidekicks. The dragons are kitten-scale, and provide bioluminescence in lieu of lanterns. Kamzin has a fox familiar, and Lusha has several raven friends.
Neat fantasy!Tibetan worldbuilding from book 1:
It was a finely carved wooden chest painted in bright reds and blues, lined with niches for ceramic statues representing generations of ancestors. Most of the little doors were closed, but one was ajar, revealing an empty shelf.
I knelt before the shrine and opened the first door, my fingers brushing against the patterns of overlapping knots carved into the wood. The statue behind it was old—so old that the clay was discolored and crumbling. The statues were not made to be recognizable, however; they were always rough, only vaguely human in shape, and meant to decay over time. I traced the character carved into the base—my great-great-grandmother’s name. I carefully returned the statue to its niche and examined the other shelves.
And realistic consequences of magic from book 2:
I shivered at the reminder of Emperor Lozong’s unnatural life span. It was said that he had ruled for over two centuries, kept alive by some strange shamanic spell. Most outside the Three Cities believed it a tale invented by the first Lozong’s descendants to intimidate his enemies.
The bad news is that a lot of this is what I call "YA as pejorative." First person ambitious teenage girl narration--none of this is a bad thing in and of itself, but in combination with embarrassing misunderstandings, making dumb decisions when drunk, love triangles, just happening to get help from allies who make unnecessary prophecies...it can be kind of painful. (Book 2 was better than 1 in this regard, there was another case of "oops, uncomfortable misunderstanding" but that one felt more like an "okay, well-played.) Kamzin's best friend accompanies her to the high altitudes despite having fantasy asthma and it's like...why are you doing this. Everyone is teenagers and thinking with their hormones, I get it. If we cut out all the "gosh, I don't know if I can trust this person, given everything that's happened, but I really want to!" it would be a lot shorter.
There are several things in book 1 that I think could have been introduced earlier. Like, we mention something, and then a chapter later we mention it again, and it's like...you could have just given that detail the first time. (Aimo and Dargye are siblings; seers like Yonden (and eventually Lusha) can't really have romantic relationships; Tem and Kamzin briefly dated, but it didn't work out; there's a witch empress who is very scary.)
River comes from a family of four brothers. The boys are Sky, River, Thorn, and...
Esha. What's going on here. This is like the "Esha's mom has four sons" puzzle.
Spoilery things:
( Read more... )Bingo: I plan to use "Wandering Light" for Last In A Series. "Darkest Stars" would count for Generic Title. Both of them are A Book In Parts. I think you could make the case that the "sky city" showing up towards the end of "Wandering Light" counts as Impossible Places.