Yeah, I think we should do an evidence post for Enlightenment, in particular why we think it's *distinct* from Frederician RPF. Then we can also link to last year's post, in case they have any questions -- but they probably won't, as morbane is my DW friend and will remember having seen it :)
(I'm a little out of my depth here, so I'd ideally like one of you guys to at least write a rough draft, though if you want me to I'll take a stab.)
OK, thanks! Knowing the names is very helpful :) Oh, and this reminds me -- in the evidence post we should probably also mention that this Richelieu is not Armand du Plessis, in case others are as confused as I am :)
Possible issue with the fandom: The era overlaps with 18th Century Frederician fandom in terms of dates.
Why this fandom should be considered eligible: While the Frederician fandom focuses on a cast strongly connected to Friedrich II. of Prussia, "European Enlightenment" stands for an international cast of scientists, philosophers, writers and society people, most of whom don't have a connection to Friedrich, whose dynamics with each other we want to explore. If we nominate someone like Émilie du Chatelet or Lady Mary Wortley-Montagu, we want the focus to be on them as protagonists of the European Enlightenment in their own right. Morever, knowledge of them does not require knowledge of Prussian history, which, by contrast, is very important in the Frederician fandom.
Also, as a character note: we are nominating Armand de Vignerot du Plessis (1696-1788), Duc de Richelieu, who does not currently have a tag on AO3. Note that he is distinct from the more famous Cardinal Richelieu, Armand Jean du Plessis de Richelieu (1585-1642).
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
(I'm a little out of my depth here, so I'd ideally like one of you guys to at least write a rough draft, though if you want me to I'll take a stab.)
OK, thanks! Knowing the names is very helpful :) Oh, and this reminds me -- in the evidence post we should probably also mention that this Richelieu is not Armand du Plessis, in case others are as confused as I am :)
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
Can you link us to the Frederican justification from last year, if you can find it, so we can use it as a model for the Enlightenment one?
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
Fandom: 18th Century European Enlightenment
Possible issue with the fandom: The era overlaps with 18th Century Frederician fandom in terms of dates.
Why this fandom should be considered eligible: While the Frederician fandom focuses on a cast strongly connected to Friedrich II. of Prussia, "European Enlightenment" stands for an international cast of scientists, philosophers, writers and society people, most of whom don't have a connection to Friedrich, whose dynamics with each other we want to explore. If we nominate someone like Émilie du Chatelet or Lady Mary Wortley-Montagu, we want the focus to be on them as protagonists of the European Enlightenment in their own right. Morever, knowledge of them does not require knowledge of Prussian history, which, by contrast, is very important in the Frederician fandom.
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
Re: Yuletide Nominations, Redux
Also, as a character note: we are nominating Armand de Vignerot du Plessis (1696-1788), Duc de Richelieu, who does not currently have a tag on AO3. Note that he is distinct from the more famous Cardinal Richelieu, Armand Jean du Plessis de Richelieu (1585-1642).